2023 Ethan McDonald - Muskingum (MVP) Jonathon Mong - Bowling Green State Brandon Vallone - William Paterson Johann Gamo - William Paterson Drake Bazzy - UW Whitewater Jerry Moua - Cal State Fresno
2022 Angelo Biondo - Wright State (MVP) Jerry Moua - Cal State Fresno Cameron Klein - Adrian College Tiler Levesque - William Paterson Jacob Zondlak - UW Stout
2021 Brandon Mooney - UW Whitewater (MVP) Steven Kocher, Bowling Green State Connor Kottke, Central Missouri Caleb Kirby, Lewis University Quinn Sheehy, UW Whitewater
2020 No Tournament Held (Coronavirus)
2019 Josh Schneider - UW Whitewater (MVP) Andrew Dekowski - William Paterson Brandon Flemming - Wright State Jacob Dunnum - UW Lacrosse Travis Kominek - Toledo
2018 Josh Pate, UW Whitewater (MVP) Jake Rollins, William Paterson Steve Kotowski, William Paterson Brandon Flemming, Wright State Chris Wiley, UW Whitewater
2017 Jake Rollins, William Paterson (MVP) Andrew Dekowski, William Paterson Jace Miyagi, Purdue Zach Woelfel, UW Whitewater Dustin Zehner, Purdue
2016 Nick Kruml, UW Whitewater (MVP) Jake Epstein, Illinois State Brady Colip, Purdue Jacob Yazell, Morehead State Zack Hattori, San Jose State
2015 Devon Miller, Morehead State (MVP) Riley Chin, Fresno State Dylan Burns, Kansas Dan Reinke, UW Whitewater Benjamin Canfield, Arizona State
2014 Chris Weber, Ohio State (MVP) Andrew Surseba, William Paterson Jacob Wright, Purdue Chris Via, Notre Dame College Devon Miller, Morehead State AJ Johnson, McKendree
