2022 Abbey Ambroza - Ohio State University (MVP) Abigail Bird - Adrian College Morgan Brooks - UW Milwaukee Rachel Kuczajda - Alma College Sophia Fischer - Wright State University
2021 Rachel Kuczajda, Alma College (MVP) Abigail Bird, Adrian College Britni Hosterman, Bowling Green State University Paige Stokes, Northern Kentucky University Briann McKnight, Wright State University
2020 No Tournament Held (Coronavirus)
2019 Tori Pappas - Wright State (MVP) Kaitlyn Schroyer - West Texas A&M Skyler Malcolm - UW Milwaukee Madison Stiffler - Wright State Sydney Renner - Northern Kentucky
2018 Tori Pappas, Wright State (MVP) Rachel Bianculli, Bowling Green State Colleen Hines, Wright State Courtney Chaffin, Morehead State Alexis Cox, Purdue
2017 Megan Szczepanski, Bellarmine (MVP) Brittney Antonelli, Adrian Keri Molloy, Saginaw Valley Marissa Thomas, Bellarmine Andrea Staples, MN State Mankato Mikayla Ebert, MN State Mankato
2016 Megan Szczepanski, Bellarmine (MVP) Colleen Hines, Wright State Kaitlyn Kinnaird, Morehead State Jessica Wolfe, Wright State Marissa Thomas, Bellarmine
2015 Shannon DeWitt, Wright State (MVP) Noelle Scheuer, Adrian College Talia St. Angelo, Fresno State Cortney Dingledine, Wright State Kayla Miller, Bowling Green
2014 Brittany Kaelin, Bellarmine (MVP) Kayla Miller, Bowling Green State (MVP) Brittney Antonelli, Adrian Kelli Lackey, UW Green Bay Amber Schulz, UW Platteville
